Sorry, guys! During system maintenance, some functions like comment are unavailable.
sidney June 24, 2026 3:51 am

I don't even know what to say i just know im going to get HATED on if i try asking this. Ill put this as spoilers but why the heck did Jax put such a weird trope the whole "im your humble slave" im sorry but what even happened during Jax's month of working on stories or whatever? I don't know much about American history but I know like half imo like many others I feel this was kinda weird. Why did we have to have this theme and not idk keep the cowboys but add yearning or something? I'm genuinely confused, also the war part sounded strange like what side was he fighting?? I'm kinda sad because I read Under the Greenlight and half of Walk on Water, so like nothing could prepare me for this. AGAIN let me clarify im not trying to be a hater but i think Jax needs to fix this story because how can anyone read this after what seems to me like there needs to be more research about cultures and etc. Do correct me if im wrong im just trying to wrap my head around this.

    sidney June 24, 2026 3:54 am

    Also I don't think freeing a person was that easy in history because in this story bro literally gives cash to the people..? I'll prob have to double-check that but it just was very weird reading this so im not sure....

    noewhale June 24, 2026 4:19 am

    Hi! probs don’t want a history lesson but if you want to read more of this story a bit of US history clarification might be helpful. So from my understanding Gerald fought for the Union, which was ‘against slavery.’ I put that in quotations bc it REALLY is not that simple as some Union families did own slaves. So can be Union and slave owner but ig Jaxx is trying to portray Gerald as not one of the bad guys ie white racist. The freeing part of the slaves I also don’t know all well but I believe in theory cash would work to kinda ‘let them go’ in a sense, but institutional barriers would limit actually freedom. Def not sure how this is going to go and so far not feeling this is the journey a smutty bl should take at all unless dealt with extreme care maybe. anyway that was long hope i gave a bit of clarity xx

    sidney June 24, 2026 2:23 pm
    Hi! probs don’t want a history lesson but if you want to read more of this story a bit of US history clarification might be helpful. So from my understanding Gerald fought for the Union, which was ‘against ... noewhale

    thanks for explaining yea that makes more sense on the question I asked but yes i do agree its very complex situation i do think this story needs to be reworked again because it's very upsetting to read. Again thanks for explaining you were very helpful!! :)

sidney June 18, 2026 7:43 pm

I read like half of Red Candy and I loved the story but cmon bro what are we doing?? There's no way BL authors dont know how to write a story without rape like what was the point in having this scene? It doesn't add value to the plot at ALL this has to be a joke right.... oh and the part where "dont make me have to bedriddern you" or whatever bro said HELLO??? What is this rip off killing stalking oh my gosh. The art is so pretty but I fear im prob dropping this bc im so icked by it like im not trying to hate but at this point it feels like ppl LOVE adding their rape kinks to stories or something oml. I forgot who said it but there's no way we can justify the rape scene bc the title is Bad Apple and "omg guys u shouldve known this would happen bc the title" that makes no sense at all but idek.

sidney June 15, 2026 7:00 pm

lord... where do i start not only does bwat make such an amazing story with beautiful art and the clothes.. its so peak ik bwat is working through an injury and recovering but gosh its so 10/10. It is worth the wait for each chapter just to see this masterpiece. I had to fan myself when i finished reading chapter 29 hahajaha

sidney June 11, 2026 7:29 pm

i dont think ill keep reading this story bc of one of the scenes where it was kinda non con idk at first i thought was red flag story yk but i think ill drop this. The art was so good tho just the drugged sex was kinda a I think im out notice. I do wish the author all the best but its just not for me.

    Ayaka Amori June 15, 2026 3:45 pm

    Yeah I died at "I don't sleep with a drugged person" and the following "you know what I think I will sleep with you anyway"

    sidney June 15, 2026 6:52 pm
    Yeah I died at "I don't sleep with a drugged person" and the following "you know what I think I will sleep with you anyway" Ayaka Amori

    right yeaaa idkk like it sounds so twisted if it didnt have this stuff id prob read it but just sucks cuz i rlly liked it D:

    I think its a trend for some BLs to have this non con stuff which is like why ??

    Ayaka Amori June 15, 2026 8:08 pm
    right yeaaa idkk like it sounds so twisted if it didnt have this stuff id prob read it but just sucks cuz i rlly liked it D:I think its a trend for some BLs to have this non con stuff which is like why ?? sidney

    I think since the beginning there is more non con bl than normal ones, but there's thankfully more with con recently, honestly those days if I want to read something normal with con and plot I just go to shonen ai, bit it's sadly lacks spice

sidney June 8, 2026 4:52 pm

wow... what a load of emotions i had to pause because i was dying of laughter. I cant wait for the next chapter and like many others have said its rlly great they're actually starting to communicate instead of this cat and mouse game.

sidney May 26, 2026 1:09 am

bro went full swat mode lol??? I see u bro i mean makes sense cuz he has some history i think. I wonder what will happen next. Also why couldnt bro jus order a watch?

    Katsura May 26, 2026 1:10 am

    My theory is that he went for a ring, not a watch, but he wasn't going to say that. Remember the actress that told him to proposed?

    pauwerrrs May 26, 2026 1:14 am
    My theory is that he went for a ring, not a watch, but he wasn't going to say that. Remember the actress that told him to proposed? Katsura

    i agree with this

    sidney May 26, 2026 5:27 pm
    My theory is that he went for a ring, not a watch, but he wasn't going to say that. Remember the actress that told him to proposed? Katsura

    i like that theory i actually forgot about that convo but yess makes more sense

sidney May 26, 2026 1:03 am

not complaining or anything but every time theres a double upload im sad thinking theres a new chapter. I will check later if they got a novel but its perf bro.

sidney May 26, 2026 1:00 am

hope that bwat takes some rest to heal not only physically but emotionally. I am happy about the note cuz after s1 I think s2 is going to be good. It's peak so lets see what's coming soon. :)

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.