I don’t think this manga will ever end to be honest not that i’m necessarily complaining. I think we at least have a 100 more chapters. Also Ciel is such a diva.
While I agree that the chapters are frustratingly short, throwing around the words stingy and milking is a bit much. Yana is taking breaks, and I heard that she's struggling with her health. Im just glad that we're getting chapters at all.
I would rather not getting chapters for a while and have her actually take an hiatus to get a real rest. Seriously, I started reading this twice a year to feel like I am actually reading something.
I would rather not getting chapters for a while and have her actually take an hiatus to get a real rest. Seriously, I started reading this twice a year to feel like I am actually reading something. Gravenshi
While I agree that the chapters are frustratingly short, throwing around the words stingy and milking is a bit much. Yana is taking breaks, and I heard that she's struggling with her health. Im just glad that w... NotToday
Plus, doesn't she also work on twisted wonderland? She's booked and busy
Plus, doesn't she also work on twisted wonderland? She's booked and busy Sadistic Seme
She should take as much rest as she needs. I want her to come back energized with the tasty chapters she used to provide rather than 1/4 chapter content per month.
She should take as much rest as she needs. I want her to come back energized with the tasty chapters she used to provide rather than 1/4 chapter content per month. Gravenshi
You are probably a kid, who doesn't know how the adult life and work life work. As if she can do wahtever she wants, whenever she wants. There are something called "law" and "contracts". It is also pointless taking a long rest, and then coming back and continue having an unhealthy lifestyle, that whill make your health worse again. She found her balance, and we respect that. Her health and life have priority over your or my curiosity over the story.
I would rather not getting chapters for a while and have her actually take an hiatus to get a real rest. Seriously, I started reading this twice a year to feel like I am actually reading something. Gravenshi
I would like to see you work on multiple story intensive projects while your health isn't in the best condition, genuinely. Please continue to do your check in every few months thing, but dont undermine her work. And this isn't a 'im a hard-core Yana defender who turns a blind eye to everything she does' thing, this comes from a respect for the series and an understanding of how hard mangaka have it.
I would like to see you work on multiple story intensive projects while your health isn't in the best condition, genuinely. Please continue to do your check in every few months thing, but dont undermine her wor... NotToday
I do not understand what you are antagonizing. I am saying that she should rest and come back stronger when healthy. Am I not speaking English or?
You are probably a kid, who doesn't know how the adult life and work life work. As if she can do wahtever she wants, whenever she wants. There are something called "law" and "contracts". It is also pointless ta... The_Devils_Advocate
You are free to believe whatever you want. After all, you are the one choosing to argue with someone you assume is a minor on an spicy website. Odd.
As for laws and contracts—I doubt you are familiar with Japanese labor laws or the exact terms of her contract. In my country, work insurance and government programs cover medical leave, and private insurance can handle the legal and financial side of health-related time off. Furthermore, from a purely economic standpoint, an unwell author is a much riskier investment than a healthy one. Honestly, I’m only humoring your shallow argument at this point.
I am not asking her to work herself to death for this series; I simply find the recent schedule underwhelming. If she is struggling with her health, I would much rather she take a break and focus on recovering than push herself to the limit for every single panel.
Of course, I’m not begging you to share my view. I see things my ways. You see thing your ways.
You are free to believe whatever you want. After all, you are the one choosing to argue with someone you assume is a minor on an spicy website. Odd.As for laws and contracts—I doubt you are familiar with Japa... Gravenshi
I don't think you are a minor, I said you are a kid. Your comments already told me that you are egocentric with little knowledge about the world, but I didn't think you wouldn't understand the meaning behind words. I am well aware how the Japanese society works, how people work themself to death, and how little power mangakas have. You should really get off the internet, and learn more about the world outside and learn what goes on in the world, instead of conplaining on a piracy website, about how some stranger doesn't work her ass off just so that you and your kind are happy. Using piracy websites instead of supporting the mangaka, and still having the courage to conplain.
I don't think you are a minor, I said you are a kid. Your comments already told me that you are egocentric with little knowledge about the world, but I didn't think you wouldn't understand the meaning behind wo... The_Devils_Advocate
Creepy. Unless someone here doesn't understand English, a kid is a minor. Regardless, it doesn't change the subject at hand. You aren't the first person to think ad hominem and ad personam are relevant substitutes for an actual argument. How about you take your own advice?—Maybe log off the internet and learn the basic argumentation. Come one! Learn more about the world outside instead of arguing with kids.
Yes, you believe you are well aware—about basics we knew over decades about the industry. Yana Toboso isn't just any mangaka. In a negotiation, she holds significant leverage—bargaining power earned through years of proven commercial success that actually carries weight. Creators at Toboso's tier have dedicated agents, managers, and legal teams who negotiate publishing contracts, royalties, and hiatus terms directly with executives.
"My kind of people" are the ones who'd be more than happy if she took even more time off—if it helps her health and the quality of her work, I'm all for it. "Your kind of people" are the ones okay with her working herself into the ground to deliver a quarter of a chapter a month, while acting like we're the crazy ones. Okay, buddy.
Aren't you on this exact same website, complaining over a kind of people you know almost nothing of? You're right here too, pointing fingers and playing the white knight while doing the exact same thing you condemn. Don't play the hypocrisy and circular argument game with me—You may believe that I am a kid, but I wasn't born yesterday either. Ah, the well-known Gatekeeping Fallacy, good old tactic used to dodge criticism when someone can't actually refute the point being made. I am sorry to inform you, but criticism rights and access rights are entirely separate issues.
Creepy. Unless someone here doesn't understand English, a kid is a minor. Regardless, it doesn't change the subject at hand. You aren't the first person to think ad hominem and ad personam are relevant substitu... Gravenshi
Since you want to police speech and put a price tag on basic freedom of expression: for the record, I've watched her series on TV, through subscription platforms, and in movie theaters—as well as other projects she's worked on behind the scenes. So yeah... just saying. ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭
Creepy. Unless someone here doesn't understand English, a kid is a minor. Regardless, it doesn't change the subject at hand. You aren't the first person to think ad hominem and ad personam are relevant substitu... Gravenshi
Such a long reply just for confirming what I am saying all time. And no, I am not doing the same thing as you. I am not conplaining about an author which work I pirate and don't support, because they don't do 100 pages each month, so I can do something in my boring life, I am simply telling how childish and egoistic your behaviour is. I don't need to know anything else about you and who you are, because your comments, which I am replying to, are proof enough. I now you are not smart enough to understand that, and try to twist everything in your favor. People never like it when they get called out for their shitty behaviour. Especially kiddos. You clearly live in a fairy tale world, that only exsists in your mind. The world is not how you want it to be, but much worse. The mangaka owns you nothing, and so i will tell you one last time, be less hypocrity and start supporting the author, instead of conplaining about her work you are accessing for free, without ehr consent. Sayonara kiddo, try to grow up and learn common sense.
Since you want to police speech and put a price tag on basic freedom of expression: for the record, I've watched her series on TV, through subscription platforms, and in movie theaters—as well as other projec... Gravenshi
Yeah sure, and I am Queen Vicotrias secret child. Still doesn't change the fact that you are reading it here, on a piracy site. And the same goes for all the other stuff you read here. Hypocrisy is your main name. BB
Since you want to police speech and put a price tag on basic freedom of expression: for the record, I've watched her series on TV, through subscription platforms, and in movie theaters—as well as other projec... Gravenshi
False you could be 18-22 you are still considered a kid in a lot of places as long as ur under 25 describing someone as a kid is also a thing its actually weirder your pinning this one someone trying to make them look like a creep minors on websites like these exist as well should they? Absolutely not but that doesn't stop anyone including me as a child who roamed the internet. I am now an adult but even i would describe myself as a kid because i am still young and aren't as wise as a full grown adult
False you could be 18-22 you are still considered a kid in a lot of places as long as ur under 25 describing someone as a kid is also a thing its actually weirder your pinning this one someone trying to make th... Weenie5
Legally no, though casually and socially it can be true. In the UK, North America, UE, and most parts of the world, anyone aged 18 or older is legally an adult. However, the way people use the word "kid" in everyday conversation is much looser.
People under 24–25 aren't considered 'kids' or 'minors'—in many legal and tax systems, they're simply classified as 'financially dependent' (such as full-time students).
"Kid" isn't a strict legal term—"minor" is. While countries set their own age of majority, in standard English (both in the UK and North America), "kid" refers to a child or minor, which ends at 18. Since I am speaking English, I am using... well... English definitions.
You're free to personally view people under 25 as kids if you want—everyone is entitled to their own perspective. :)
Since you want to police speech and put a price tag on basic freedom of expression: for the record, I've watched her series on TV, through subscription platforms, and in movie theaters—as well as other projec... Gravenshi
What was the point of starting all that whining just to rage-quit and blockpeople? Guess somebody did not like their own words being thrown back at them.
A famous philosopher once describes resorting to insults as the "last trick" of someone who knows they have lost the argument. The very final one is becoming personal, insulting, and rude. It is an admission of defeat: they abandon the actual topic and attack the other person's character. It requires zero intelligence, logic, truth, or skill. It stems from wounded vanity. It adds zero value and only shows an inability to hold a proper conversation.
If wishing for someone to take as much time off as they need to rest and be healthier so they can work at their prime instead of killing themselves over a few panels makes me egocentric with a shitty personality, I’ll happily take it. :).
Legally no, though casually and socially it can be true. In the UK, North America, UE, and most parts of the world, anyone aged 18 or older is legally an adult. However, the way people use the word "kid" in eve... Gravenshi
Thats what i meant most people personally think that its not meant to be taken in a literal way and thats what this person meant, speaking to you is like chat gpt is a person
Thats what i meant most people personally think that its not meant to be taken in a literal way and thats what this person meant, speaking to you is like chat gpt is a person Weenie5
╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭ I was humoring them. Imagine someone out of nowhere calling you a kid with no life experience. I felt like giving them what they asked for.
Yeah sure, and I am Queen Vicotrias secret child. Still doesn't change the fact that you are reading it here, on a piracy site. And the same goes for all the other stuff you read here. Hypocrisy is your main na... The_Devils_Advocate
never seen someone get this mad over ppl wishing sensei good health... And the 2 cents virtue-signalin with a name like devil's advocate ffs plus you're the one who drpd that mid hypocrisy 'no pay, no opinion'. What a load of bs! I've a Lezhin account myself, but I come here for faster translations and the dynamic chats. It always kills me when ppl trashtalk others and then act all holier-than-thou! lwk I laughed at the whole mess
never seen someone get this mad over ppl wishing sensei good health... And the 2 cents virtue-signalin with a name like devil's advocate ffs plus you're the one who drpd that mid hypocrisy 'no pay, no opinion'.... Sasuga Natsume
Even after those years it seem we have answer but we don't have real answer to all this. I'm so desperate to know what will happen, what is turth behind all of this, and I HAVE MORE QUESTIONS
I mean, for all intents and purposes, Sebastian IS evil, and Ciel has done evil things. Wanting Sebastian to be defeated is my typical morality at play, especially with the emotional aspects being so raw and real. But question: how EXACTLY are Ciel and Sebastian tied? There's the obvious contract, but Sebastian's verbiage made it sound almost like their lives were intertwined. If that's correct, that wouldn't really matter for Sebastian, since he's gonna devour Ciel anyway, and thus only means something if he dies, since that could kill Ciel. But doesn't Ciel's contract include protecting him? If he ends up hurt (you know, like he has), doesn't that mean the contract is broken because Sebastian failed to uphold his end of the deal? There goes my brain.
If 'failing to protect him' would break the contract, the contract would've been broken a fair amount of times. Getting kidnapped could be seen as a failure, ciel getting injured or scuffed up like he has in the past could count, its all a lot. I belive whats going on is that since Ciel is Sebastian's meal at the end of all of this, making sure Ciel makes it out of things in one peice if his priority. Plus, in the Green Witch arc, Sebastian was fully ready to eat Ciel because Ciel had seemingly 'given up' on his end of the deal due to his frightened state.
What im trying to say is I think the connection is through intention, but the Demon also has the power. Once you enter a contract, there's seemingly no backing out of it. Its like paying an construction worker or something an advance on a job, a sum of the promised currency to prove that yes, you want this thing built, and you will pay for it. Now its really complicated to scrap construction when the foundations laid and the walls are halfway up, so if you dont want it that building anymore...there's no really going back. There's repercussions for doing that- it would be a waste of money, a waste of time, and those workers probably wont be too happy that a high paying jobs been canceled. They still have that chunk of your money, so why not just see it through to the end?
Okay, that was a long winded explanation, but TLDR there's bound to be consequences if the deal breaks, if at all. Im sure there's some dark freaky magic going on that makes it near impossible to break a contract. Idk, these are theories from a heavily medicated welding major.
If 'failing to protect him' would break the contract, the contract would've been broken a fair amount of times. Getting kidnapped could be seen as a failure, ciel getting injured or scuffed up like he has in th... NotToday
See that's what I thought--but it works both ways, right? Sebastian HAS to fufill his end; that's the whole reason he hasn't devoured Ciel yet. This contract has certain addendums, ie not lying and protecting Ciel. Even IRL contracts can be broken--Sebastian isn't getting an advance on this at all; Ciel isn't giving him other souls to tithe him over or "incentivize" him.
I do wonder if that's just a big plot hole Yana never really caught onto. But I do appreciate the response!
See that's what I thought--but it works both ways, right? Sebastian HAS to fufill his end; that's the whole reason he hasn't devoured Ciel yet. This contract has certain addendums, ie not lying and protecting C... Baras Son
Maybe its his pride as a demon? He clearly enjoys the butler aesthetic. That may be enough to incentive him
Topics
Using a demon to fight a demon under the guise of holiness. I like the hypocrisy of everyone
Am I the only one who likes sebastian?? And undertaker too?
Why do u think most of us are still here?
Though I'm curious how this manga would end too
I haven't read this manga for 15 years for someone to think they are the only one who likes Sebastian (/TДT)/
HAH I KNEW IT WASN'T SEBASTIAN!
SEBASTIAN HAS CUNTY HEELS
I don’t think this manga will ever end to be honest not that i’m necessarily complaining. I think we at least have a 100 more chapters. Also Ciel is such a diva.
ouuu shii
whodat
Lol. That author sure got stingier as the years went. Milking. Slacking. Barely producing 1/4 of a real chapter... PER MONTH.
While I agree that the chapters are frustratingly short, throwing around the words stingy and milking is a bit much. Yana is taking breaks, and I heard that she's struggling with her health. Im just glad that we're getting chapters at all.
I would rather not getting chapters for a while and have her actually take an hiatus to get a real rest.
Seriously, I started reading this twice a year to feel like I am actually reading something.
Yana actually did take a hiatus hello
Plus, doesn't she also work on twisted wonderland? She's booked and busy
She should take as much rest as she needs. I want her to come back energized with the tasty chapters she used to provide rather than 1/4 chapter content per month.
You are probably a kid, who doesn't know how the adult life and work life work. As if she can do wahtever she wants, whenever she wants. There are something called "law" and "contracts". It is also pointless taking a long rest, and then coming back and continue having an unhealthy lifestyle, that whill make your health worse again. She found her balance, and we respect that. Her health and life have priority over your or my curiosity over the story.
I would like to see you work on multiple story intensive projects while your health isn't in the best condition, genuinely. Please continue to do your check in every few months thing, but dont undermine her work. And this isn't a 'im a hard-core Yana defender who turns a blind eye to everything she does' thing, this comes from a respect for the series and an understanding of how hard mangaka have it.
I do not understand what you are antagonizing. I am saying that she should rest and come back stronger when healthy. Am I not speaking English or?
You are free to believe whatever you want. After all, you are the one choosing to argue with someone you assume is a minor on an spicy website. Odd.
As for laws and contracts—I doubt you are familiar with Japanese labor laws or the exact terms of her contract. In my country, work insurance and government programs cover medical leave, and private insurance can handle the legal and financial side of health-related time off. Furthermore, from a purely economic standpoint, an unwell author is a much riskier investment than a healthy one. Honestly, I’m only humoring your shallow argument at this point.
I am not asking her to work herself to death for this series; I simply find the recent schedule underwhelming. If she is struggling with her health, I would much rather she take a break and focus on recovering than push herself to the limit for every single panel.
Of course, I’m not begging you to share my view. I see things my ways. You see thing your ways.
I don't think you are a minor, I said you are a kid. Your comments already told me that you are egocentric with little knowledge about the world, but I didn't think you wouldn't understand the meaning behind words.
I am well aware how the Japanese society works, how people work themself to death, and how little power mangakas have.
You should really get off the internet, and learn more about the world outside and learn what goes on in the world, instead of conplaining on a piracy website, about how some stranger doesn't work her ass off just so that you and your kind are happy.
Using piracy websites instead of supporting the mangaka, and still having the courage to conplain.
Creepy. Unless someone here doesn't understand English, a kid is a minor. Regardless, it doesn't change the subject at hand. You aren't the first person to think ad hominem and ad personam are relevant substitutes for an actual argument. How about you take your own advice?—Maybe log off the internet and learn the basic argumentation. Come one! Learn more about the world outside instead of arguing with kids.
Yes, you believe you are well aware—about basics we knew over decades about the industry. Yana Toboso isn't just any mangaka. In a negotiation, she holds significant leverage—bargaining power earned through years of proven commercial success that actually carries weight. Creators at Toboso's tier have dedicated agents, managers, and legal teams who negotiate publishing contracts, royalties, and hiatus terms directly with executives.
"My kind of people" are the ones who'd be more than happy if she took even more time off—if it helps her health and the quality of her work, I'm all for it. "Your kind of people" are the ones okay with her working herself into the ground to deliver a quarter of a chapter a month, while acting like we're the crazy ones. Okay, buddy.
Aren't you on this exact same website, complaining over a kind of people you know almost nothing of? You're right here too, pointing fingers and playing the white knight while doing the exact same thing you condemn. Don't play the hypocrisy and circular argument game with me—You may believe that I am a kid, but I wasn't born yesterday either. Ah, the well-known Gatekeeping Fallacy, good old tactic used to dodge criticism when someone can't actually refute the point being made. I am sorry to inform you, but criticism rights and access rights are entirely separate issues.
Since you want to police speech and put a price tag on basic freedom of expression: for the record, I've watched her series on TV, through subscription platforms, and in movie theaters—as well as other projects she's worked on behind the scenes. So yeah... just saying. ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭
Such a long reply just for confirming what I am saying all time. And no, I am not doing the same thing as you. I am not conplaining about an author which work I pirate and don't support, because they don't do 100 pages each month, so I can do something in my boring life, I am simply telling how childish and egoistic your behaviour is. I don't need to know anything else about you and who you are, because your comments, which I am replying to, are proof enough. I now you are not smart enough to understand that, and try to twist everything in your favor. People never like it when they get called out for their shitty behaviour. Especially kiddos. You clearly live in a fairy tale world, that only exsists in your mind. The world is not how you want it to be, but much worse. The mangaka owns you nothing, and so i will tell you one last time, be less hypocrity and start supporting the author, instead of conplaining about her work you are accessing for free, without ehr consent. Sayonara kiddo, try to grow up and learn common sense.
Yeah sure, and I am Queen Vicotrias secret child. Still doesn't change the fact that you are reading it here, on a piracy site. And the same goes for all the other stuff you read here. Hypocrisy is your main name. BB
False you could be 18-22 you are still considered a kid in a lot of places as long as ur under 25 describing someone as a kid is also a thing its actually weirder your pinning this one someone trying to make them look like a creep minors on websites like these exist as well should they? Absolutely not but that doesn't stop anyone including me as a child who roamed the internet. I am now an adult but even i would describe myself as a kid because i am still young and aren't as wise as a full grown adult
Legally no, though casually and socially it can be true. In the UK, North America, UE, and most parts of the world, anyone aged 18 or older is legally an adult. However, the way people use the word "kid" in everyday conversation is much looser.
People under 24–25 aren't considered 'kids' or 'minors'—in many legal and tax systems, they're simply classified as 'financially dependent' (such as full-time students).
"Kid" isn't a strict legal term—"minor" is. While countries set their own age of majority, in standard English (both in the UK and North America), "kid" refers to a child or minor, which ends at 18. Since I am speaking English, I am using... well... English definitions.
You're free to personally view people under 25 as kids if you want—everyone is entitled to their own perspective. :)
What was the point of starting all that whining just to rage-quit and blockpeople? Guess somebody did not like their own words being thrown back at them.
A famous philosopher once describes resorting to insults as the "last trick" of someone who knows they have lost the argument. The very final one is becoming personal, insulting, and rude. It is an admission of defeat: they abandon the actual topic and attack the other person's character. It requires zero intelligence, logic, truth, or skill. It stems from wounded vanity. It adds zero value and only shows an inability to hold a proper conversation.
If wishing for someone to take as much time off as they need to rest and be healthier so they can work at their prime instead of killing themselves over a few panels makes me egocentric with a shitty personality, I’ll happily take it. :).
Thats what i meant most people personally think that its not meant to be taken in a literal way and thats what this person meant, speaking to you is like chat gpt is a person
╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭ I was humoring them. Imagine someone out of nowhere calling you a kid with no life experience. I felt like giving them what they asked for.
never seen someone get this mad over ppl wishing sensei good health... And the 2 cents virtue-signalin with a name like devil's advocate ffs plus you're the one who drpd that mid hypocrisy 'no pay, no opinion'. What a load of bs! I've a Lezhin account myself, but I come here for faster translations and the dynamic chats. It always kills me when ppl trashtalk others and then act all holier-than-thou! lwk I laughed at the whole mess
There is a first to everything. ( ̄∇ ̄")
Even after those years it seem we have answer but we don't have real answer to all this. I'm so desperate to know what will happen, what is turth behind all of this, and I HAVE MORE QUESTIONS
I mean, for all intents and purposes, Sebastian IS evil, and Ciel has done evil things. Wanting Sebastian to be defeated is my typical morality at play, especially with the emotional aspects being so raw and real. But question: how EXACTLY are Ciel and Sebastian tied? There's the obvious contract, but Sebastian's verbiage made it sound almost like their lives were intertwined. If that's correct, that wouldn't really matter for Sebastian, since he's gonna devour Ciel anyway, and thus only means something if he dies, since that could kill Ciel. But doesn't Ciel's contract include protecting him? If he ends up hurt (you know, like he has), doesn't that mean the contract is broken because Sebastian failed to uphold his end of the deal? There goes my brain.
If 'failing to protect him' would break the contract, the contract would've been broken a fair amount of times. Getting kidnapped could be seen as a failure, ciel getting injured or scuffed up like he has in the past could count, its all a lot. I belive whats going on is that since Ciel is Sebastian's meal at the end of all of this, making sure Ciel makes it out of things in one peice if his priority. Plus, in the Green Witch arc, Sebastian was fully ready to eat Ciel because Ciel had seemingly 'given up' on his end of the deal due to his frightened state.
What im trying to say is I think the connection is through intention, but the Demon also has the power. Once you enter a contract, there's seemingly no backing out of it. Its like paying an construction worker or something an advance on a job, a sum of the promised currency to prove that yes, you want this thing built, and you will pay for it. Now its really complicated to scrap construction when the foundations laid and the walls are halfway up, so if you dont want it that building anymore...there's no really going back. There's repercussions for doing that- it would be a waste of money, a waste of time, and those workers probably wont be too happy that a high paying jobs been canceled. They still have that chunk of your money, so why not just see it through to the end?
Okay, that was a long winded explanation, but TLDR there's bound to be consequences if the deal breaks, if at all. Im sure there's some dark freaky magic going on that makes it near impossible to break a contract. Idk, these are theories from a heavily medicated welding major.
See that's what I thought--but it works both ways, right? Sebastian HAS to fufill his end; that's the whole reason he hasn't devoured Ciel yet. This contract has certain addendums, ie not lying and protecting Ciel. Even IRL contracts can be broken--Sebastian isn't getting an advance on this at all; Ciel isn't giving him other souls to tithe him over or "incentivize" him.
I do wonder if that's just a big plot hole Yana never really caught onto. But I do appreciate the response!
Maybe its his pride as a demon? He clearly enjoys the butler aesthetic. That may be enough to incentive him
That does still leave the question of why the heck this contract isn't broken and hasn't been before.
Plot armor. Thats all I can think of.
my dumbass read it as: The Butler, Lactating
i wish
NO CUZ SAME I THOUGHT YANA FINALLY LOST THEIR SHIT LMAOO
yooo Seb might actually get beaten up this time yaaaaay (i like to see hot ppl suffer)
bro this chapter feels like im reading a doujin lmao