Sorry, guys! During system maintenance, some functions like comment are unavailable.
KinkApex like topic of Rut Partner

He's not that bad but maybe annoying.

He only causes misunderstanding but nothing more than that, he's genuinely the type of person in love with someone engaged to him (ml)

In the end he learned to let go of ml but before letting go, he really does fight for his love, he's not a bad person, he just childish



Chapter 11 (Introduction): Haneul is first mentioned as a prominent, well‑bred Omega and classmate (turns out to be the same age, 24) of Ji‑an
. He was educated abroad and recently met Ideun. Ideun’s friend Taemin notes that Haneul has all the qualities Ideun’s grandmother would approve of in a husband (young, healthy omega from a good family)
.

Chapter 16 (Confession): After a night out, Haneul stops Ideun’s car to confess: he likes Ideun despite their eight-year age gap. Tearfully Haneul begs for a chance, saying “I like you… I love you” and insists he is willing to marry Ideun
. He protests “It’s not like I chose to be born younger” and pleads “Hyung, can you at least give me a chance?”
. Haneul proposes spending more time together so that Ideun’s feelings might change.

Chapter 18 (Heartbreak at the Bar): Haneul waits anxiously as Ideun fails to reply to his messages but instantly replies to Ji‑an’s texts. Haneul sneaks Ji‑an’s phone to test this and realizes Ideun has been attentive to Ji‑an and will pick Ji‑an up as his “guardian,” not him. Seeing Ideun’s response (addressing Ji‑an as “Are you okay?”) and later answering Ji‑an’s call blows Haneul’s mind
. He realizes Ideun came to fetch Ji‑an, not him – shattering Haneul’s hopes.

Chapter 36 (Desperate Texts to Ji‑an): The next scene shows Haneul frantically texting Ji‑an on New Year’s Eve: “Seo Ji‑an. We need to talk…” and then “Are you busy?...Aren’t you sorry? You shouldn’t treat me like….”
. Ji‑an, reading these messages, observes that “Ideun had no intention of marrying Haneul – not him, not Ideun’s grandmother….”
. Haneul’s texts reveal his anger and hurt but Ji‑an delays confronting him.

Chapter 37 (Musical Invitation): Haneul is said to have asked Ji‑an to go see a musical with him. Ideun hears Ji‑an decline, saying flatly, “I’m not going to a musical with Noh Haneul… If I were to go, it’d be with my baby”
. This illustrates Haneul’s continued attempts to engage the others and Ideun’s cold rebuff through Ji‑an.

Chapter 39 (Confronting Ji‑an): Haneul corners Ji‑an to confront him about living with Ideun. He bursts out: “I like him, Ji‑an. I love him. I want to marry him. My parents like him and his grandmother adores me. You know about the marriage talks…”
. Haneul, voice trembling, admits he’s agreed to marry Ideun and is bewildered why Ji‑an is moving in instead. Later he begs Ji‑an with tears in his eyes: “I really can’t do this without him… He says I’m too young. It’s just an eight‑year difference… Please, talk to him for me”
. He also acknowledges to Ji‑an, “I know how much you love him… I love him too,” lamenting that he “stupidly fell for him” even after Ideun once made his life “unbearable”
.

Chapter 40 (Aftermath with Ji‑an): Haneul breaks down in tears. When Ji‑an gently calls his name, Haneul sobs and says, “In the end, I’ve made you cry… I’m really nothing but a nuisance, aren’t I?”
. Ji‑an reassures him: “It’s not what you’re imagining. Above all, I’m a beta. I’ll move and quit the company… stop crying”
. Haneul, still tearful, presses Ji‑an to act now: “You don’t need more time. I’ll help you. Ideun hyung went out of town… so there’s no reason to hesitate any longer”
. This resolves the immediate crisis: Haneul accepts Ji‑an isn’t Ideun’s lover and is willing to let Ji‑an pursue Ideun.

Chapter 41 (Confronting Ideun): Haneul’s father and grandmother accompany him to demand marriage with Ideun. In a tense meeting Ideun bluntly refuses: “I have no intention of marrying Chairman Noh’s son… not me, not Grandma. She has someone else in mind”
. Ideun says he would rather see “your elder drop dead” than obey that match. Haneul cries out “Hyung!” but Ideun coolly leaves with Ji‑an. Afterward Ideun coldly explains to Haneul’s father that Haneul is “a probationary employee” at his company and “nothing more” – so Haneul’s name “won’t be on the guest list” at any wedding
. This final rejection crushes Haneul: ideologically he accepted the match, but even Ideun and his grandmother spurn him.

Chapter 42 (Memory): Although Haneul himself does not appear, Ji‑an recalls Haneul’s caring words in a dream: “He’s thinking something has changed… Let’s cherish this moment forever, just the two of us, untouched by pain”
(referring to a moment Haneul had urged Ji‑an to treasure). Ji‑an also notes in passing that Haneul was joking “about how close we were” when suggesting they go to work together
, indicating Haneul’s playful affection for Ji‑an. This underscores Haneul’s gentle side and lingering presence in Ji‑an’s mind.

Chapter 56 (Later Mentions): In a final reference, Ji‑an recalls who reacted to seeing him with Ideun: “Haneul, who had wept and wailed,” along with others like friends and Ideun’s grandmother
. This implies that, at least in memory, Haneul was intensely upset by the turn of events. No new scenes feature Haneul beyond this recollection.

KinkApex like topic of Rut Partner

I skimmed the novel because im curious about this story...
But then i found out ji-an only confronted haneul almost in the end of the story ( ̄へ ̄)(story ended at chapter 74 and haneul confronted him at chapter 68-70)
I don't know if i can handle the frustration because of that bitch haneul

KinkApex like topic of Rut Partner

Someone spoil this whole plot to me please?

KinkApex like topic of Rut Partner

Can someone spoile the rest of the story?

KinkApex like topic of The Fifth Morning

Hello guys. I have read this novel many years ago but it remains one of my fav. I'll write spoiler as below.
Is it green flag? Not necessarily. Is it red flag? Not really. It's neither.
MC : Our reincarnated war soldier, he reincarnated 4x, and this is his 5th life.
ML : his personality chance in every lifetime.
Luce : MC adopted brother & supposedly he is ML love interest in some lifetimes.

The world have magic. Male and male can be married and child can be created by magic. No yinyang. No alpha omega. Just mutual consent to create a child.

I'll tell story from the very very beginning.
MC & this luce were both street Orphans. They were not blood related. They were adopted by this uncle who raised them. They were so poor. Luce is pretty so he was being hit on a lot by creeps and MC needed to protect him.
The uncle died. MC always saw himself as stupid, so he started join like mercenary or soldier stuff, he was eager to earn money so he could send luce to magician school. Then when MC was mid teen he was recruited by aristocrat family as personal bodyguard for this young master. It was ML. ML is younger than MC. ML was kind and stuff. He taught MC to read and some knowledge. After Luce gained some knowledge as healing mage, he made luce also work in this noble family. Luce as the same age as ML. I think the gap between ML and MC was 8years.
MC fell in love with ML but he knew it was inappropriate, beside their status, MC also younger, BUT, MC loved him like non in sexual way. ML was sooo pretty. He also received same treatment like luce, creeps hit on him. ML sensed MC started liking him, so ML CHOSE to dated Luce, even tho he knew MC liked him. But it wasn't wrong, MC was older and for him he looked like creep. To not get confuse if I remember correctly it's ML probably mid teen like 16 17? (I don't remember, but he wasn't a baby).
ML deliberately made MC followed them on their date (ML & Luce). MC is very timid person ok.
Then after some years, I think MC think that Luce is all grown up now and having a good boyfriend. MC wanted to stay with ML but being mere bodyguard isn't guaranteed. So during war between human vs monster, MC joined war for 2 years. In this war if you give great contribution you could gain land and title and wealth. MC returned to ML after 2 years in battlefield.
Big Spoiler : MC asked Luce to tell ML he had returned and now he has made great contributions MC wanted to ask ML if he could like think of something for his reward from the king. Luce told MC to go away because ML hated him and disgusted by him. He hated older man liking him. MC begged but Luce turned him away. So MC finally go. ML father have been dissatisfied with Luce for so long, he told MC to ask reward for land, title and wealth. In the novel it was never clear what's the agreement between MC and ML father, what clear was ML father told MC to get that specific rewards, including which land and fief to ask from the king.
Plot twist. ML initially felt disgusted of MC as he thought MC just lusted after him like other men. But after some time he realized MC was just liking him quietly. MC was once promised to be together with ML forever. So ML waited for MC to return from battle to reconcile, he waited and waited, but what he heard was the news that MC chose to a baron and moved far away to another fiefdom. ML felt immense betrayal of their promise. Actually Luce told that lie. It never stated in novel but I think luce had long sense bothe MC and ML like each other and he just didn't like it.
Tbh the scene Luce told MC to go away and to never approach ML again was sad. MC said that luce was like a family to him, why act cruel.

Anyway return to another point. In 1st-4th timeline, MC always married Luce. ML's father made it to happen. One is to remove luce from ML's life, there are other reasons but never stated in novel. MC was a kind husband. They never intimate. MC always thought luce as family so he never hated luce. If I remember correctly, I think after some years of their marriage, let say 1 year okay, I don't remember of how many years. After 1 year of marriage, MC decided to want to divorce luce so luce can be with ML. ML who mad that MC left him and married luce, went and join war. Probably 3 years. So MC and ML waiting another years. ML returned with better achievements, I think he received title as viscoun. At least he can removed himself from his father.
1st timeline, MC told ML that he will return luce to him if ML accept his duel. They duel in front of the crowd, and MC died by ML sword.

2nd timeline,
MC woke up on his 1st year wedding anniversary with Luce. In this lifetime, he decided to not act stupid like dying. So he intended to divorce as well but still waiting for ML return from war. But something terrible happened. Suddenly MC was being framed for a crime he never did and died in execution. This was a short life.

3rd life. He again woke up at 1st wedding anniversary. Then he determined another divorce. But another event happened. Suddenly the monster attack the city and he died protecting luce.

4th life. He made a lot of preparation to divorce. He tried avoiding death flag. He sent letter to ML in battle field that he will divorce luce and he meant it. But ML and luce kept this secret in order not raise another issue. On the day ML return to war, I think, MC and Luce divorced. But suddenly before ML arrival, Luce died of poisoning. Spoiler : ML's father killed luce.
This life is very sad and long.
ML went to prison around a year or so. He suddenly was moved out from prison and moved into dungeon in ML's snowy north castle (ML castle from his reward as defeating demons in war, not Inheritance from ML's father). MC lived in captived for few years.
ML actually tried to find what happened and it was actually his father who killed luce. So ML killed him, secretly. I forgot if ML moved MC out of prison through legal or illegal meaning.
In this 4th life, ML was obsessed on MC. He had this paranoia that MC will leave him again but he also wanted to punish MC for ever leaving him. One day, suddenly MC prison's door was open. MC went outside. He even found a way to the garden. All white in snow. MC stand there and watched the moon. ML shocked to see MC wasn't in the cell and in the garden. So he hurt MC's already injured leg to make it completely limp. He wanted MC to never even dream of leaving him again.
ML then have some business in capital, so ML had to leave, he gave MC expensive fur coat. Later, ML's aide came and gave MC "strong drink", it implies that MC need to take this drink and die from poisoning. MC thought, did ML finally forgive me? Can I really die? It's okay if ML ask me to die. So MC died.
ML who returned and found MC died, went mad and crazy. He tried to revive MC in many ways. He sought out shaman and magician. And finally. ML followed MC in MC's 5th life. The 5th morning.
Another spoiler : the aide hated MC so he did kill him and made it like ML who killed MC. The aide hated MC in 1st life as well.

For context, in 1st life, MC helped rescued magical divine beast. The beast granted him reset. So MC always be reborn. But each life is "bit" different. It was supposed 3x lives. But the divine beast feel sorry for how foolish MC was. It gave MC the 4 chance to live in 5th life, but it gave MC bigger difference, and it hoped MC could finally be happy.

5th life. MC woke up at his 1st wedding year anniversary. And his husband wasn't luce. But ML. In his younger age. Like 17 or 18yo. But the catch is, this ML Inherited ML's memory from 4th life because he tried to Revived MC and died instead. The divine beast actually hated this ML for contaminating the world that it created only for MC.

This life time is much different. ML's father made ML married MC exactly for the fiefdom location and planned to kill MC to made ML Inherited MC's estates. Luce was never MC family, Luce is born in wealthiest merchant family in the country. Luce easily change lovers.
This 5th life, of course ML still stupid but it's much. Because he finally could see MC, outside prison cell and outside his job as bodyguard. MC is just very timid and kind man. With very limping leg.

MC was injured badly on his left (?) Leg, in his 1st life. Everytime MC reincarnated, his injury will getting worse so MC will be more limping than previous life. But in 4th life, ML injured him badly on his already limp leg. In this 5th life, MC couldn't walk without a cane. He will definitely fall without one. And he couldn't even run to save his life.
There are so many arcs here in 5th life, where ML finally can be honest with his own feelings.
This 5th life, MC also tried so hard to make ML and Luce back together. But ML refused divorce many times.
MC also tried to drown himself on the beach, because he thought this life also failure. ML frantically saved him. And then MC rambling about being born many times. And how ML killed him in 1st life and 4th life. ML told MC he never wanted MC to die, he never ordered a kill, and he never told Luce to throw MC out. ML thought MC betrayed him by choosing to moved away.
This life, ML also go to war, but after learning his aide killed MC, in this war, he didn't save his aid from death. He has new aide. And now higher status, as marquees. But then ML met the devine beast whom saved by MC. ML told divine beast to stop tormenting MC by giving him endless reborn. Divine beast said that it hates how ML enter the world he created for MC. Divine beast promised not to add more reincarnation, if ML pass the test. ML memories of loving MC were all erased. ML returned home from war, not remembering his own husband. Even in battlefield, everyone knew ML loved MC a lot by reading letter over and over.
Anyway, this amnesia arc isn't that anxt. It end quickly. ML fell in love again with MC. And divine beast returned his memories.
Anyway there are happy. ML chose not to have any child because it will burden MC body. ML is very very famous as doting husband. Compared to how the story started when the rumors said MC trapped ML in unwanted marriage.

Divine beast, let ML visit the 1st timeline. They are all multiverse, not regression. So the time still flow in 1st life even after MC died.
ML sees his older self (in 1st life), was lonely, depressed, and crazy. There was marriage painting with luce, but it was on the floor and very dusty. Older ML always looking for MC replacement. He always asked his aide to find him men who look like MC. But even if they were very alike, older ML will hate it because the smile or laugh differently. And the aide enjoyed that all those people being turned away.
ML thought that older ML was foolish to kill his own the love of his life. But ML also grateful he had a second chance to ammend and followed MC to this new world. ML sent like some of his voice and older ML can hear it.
ML return to present time, he left just very shortly so MC never knew he left. ML have another fear. He fear that the other MLs, from 1st - 3rd lifetimw, what if they all sought black magic and find MC in this world, but he vows he will never let any harm to MC.


I don't tell much about this lifetime but there's a lotbof arc. And no. ML don't cheat on MC with this world luce

KinkApex like topic of The Fifth Morning

Character review

• [Hernan (uke) + in his mid 30s + crippled and weak + in past he was strong man bodyguard of seme ] for 4 timelines he come between seme and luce (but not really** read my timeline details for uke efforts in each timeline after character review)
and try to have seme and he is jealous, greed and schemey type , he confessed to seme and got rejected very badly for being older and harbour feelings for seme who hates older men, in 4th timeline seme broke his right leg cuz after killing luce seme trapped uke in prison and uke decide just go out and seme broke his leg to stop him from running from him , he also consumed poison lot in 4th timeline given by seme (but not really it was seme's aid james who given it to uke without seme knowing anything about it and uke belived seme wanted him to suffer and die badly) after uke finally lost will to leave died. Then in fifth timeline uke is unexpectedly married to seme who is still 18-19 of age by society uke seen as in fifth timeline as old perverted crippled man who married beautiful seme against his will and trapped him in his scala mansion. Uke has bad reputation in 5th timeline and people just made bad assumptions about him and uke become total leg go type he doesn't care about himself anymore he wants luce and seme happiness he doesn't believe in love of his own anymore he just want anyone he hurted to be happy especially seme with his love "luce" , he also told seme he would divorce seme gladly after seme has something of his own commander title in empire till then he wanted to support seme as his spouse in name, also uke is anxious till the end of series. Uke lost his strength in 5th timeline he is weak and fragile use cane to support himself.

• [Calix (grows taller and handsome men till 23 of age + hate older man + rejected uke + become commander ] - being youngest beautiful son of his house he knew his father would married him off to an old man for benefit of his family , so uke was his bodyguard in each timeline till 5th come and he become his spouse, seme doesn't remember any of 3 timelines he only knows 4th and enter 5th cuz of black magic he used to revive dead uke , seme hated older men cuz he knows they view him only as object of lust cuz of his beauty when uke confessed to him he was young boy he badly rejected uke with harsh words and fall in love with luce who was around his age but uke always eventually kills his lover and his hatred mixed with hidden love for uke grows more than love seme was uncertain and his hatred for older men blinded him from his love for uke in 5th timeline at first he was sure he would lod luce if he keep meeting him but that didn't happen and he fall harder for uke who is now nothing but crippled man nd made him this time. Guilt and hidden feelings forms slowly and he fell harder for uke. Misunderstanding also played part in his behaviour. He learnt fighting from uke to become powerful ended up becoming empires well known commander he no longer known for his beauty but for his heroic wars. In 5th timeline he also has amnesia we get may be even without memories seme would still chose uke

• [ Luce around seme age + lover of seme)] luce in 1st timeline step brother of uke thy both were orphans and seme met him when uke once brought him on hunting competiton they become closer , although seme rejected uke they made promise in which luce told uke that "seme wanted you to die in battlefield stop hurting him" luce lied about that cuz he wanted seme for himself and uke belived seme wanted him dead so uke never met seme cuz of luce words and seme belived uke left and abandoned him. In 5th timeline luce become playboy who steals lovers of others and rich painter tooo. Luce also used to paint but in this he also did with more influence cuz he is rich boy now.

[***Timelines]
- (1st) uke schemed with seme father to kill luce after seme returned from war becoming hero , uke jealousy was at peak and seme killed uke with his own hands. (2nd) - uke understood he was wrong but couldn't survive timeline cuz monster killed him whole he tried to protect luce and (3rd)- uke turn to marry luce he try to protect luce in this too yet failed cuz he played duel match in which he married luce after seme left for war coming back in duel seme killed uke with his sword that's exactly the outcome uke wanted he thought if he died maybe seme and luce would have happy future (4th )- I m not sure how luce died in it but seme come back from war becoming hero and he locked up uke in mansion and tortured him for days with poison feeding locked up on chain till he died in this he broke his leg and felt hurt that uke abandoned him and also killed his lover luce. After uke died seme brought black magic magician ti bring uke ti life even if he is broken and scattered didn't matter he just wanted him back interruption of seme black magic and forest god's will to make uke suffer clash made possible for seme to remember 4th timeline to 5th one.

__________________________________
-[Storyline -whole spoiler with angsty]
_________________________________

Just as 5th timeline started uke was ready to hand seme to his lover or any person of his appropriate age and beautiful, divorce him with his title and wealth he has without taking anything with him, seme in beginning was confused about his feelings he tells uke harsh words then reflect on hisbehaviour he is like in rebellious phase or something uke take anything seme says to him without saying anything in return he believes every words and humiliation from seme he deserves them not love but punishment for his sins he had done as they got invited to parties people doesn't approach uke but seme , uke loved how seme was center of attention and loved by everyone just as he should and uke is happy in corner seeing this scene but seme eyes always follows uke who is always in dark just standing with his crippled leg he made , guilt and pain seme feel cuz of was beyond his understanding himself but seme become cane of uke supporting him, seme got growth spurt and his body start to hurt seme told uke to sleep beside him n one room just so seme father won't kill uke cuz they didn't have any kids yet and father see no potential in uke for giving any child, seme become obsessed and possessive of uke but uke believe "I m just a broken toy seme took interest in little once he will meet luce his only love he won't look at me then he eyes his affection everything will go to luce then i would be at peace to see this beautiful couple being happy" , always uke think of it seme eventually knows what uke is thinking, lot happens seme meet luce just as uke wanted him to always seme drag uke with him every meeting were never alone uke thought "seme wanted him to see look how perfect we are it's also bittersweet but they are beyond my reach " uke in this timeline is innocent man who holds nothing special, he is weak man now gets easily exhausted and seme always worried about him , there was painter who painted rough sketch of seme smiling who was talking to luce , uke kept that sketch in his pocket thinking " real person won't smile at me like that " painter was woman she was talent and at the end of series seme made her to paint portrait of him and uke to hang that in mansion entrance as married couple, after few meetings with luce seme comes to conclusions he is not the same luce whom he knew everything has changed and he loves uke he stopped meeting luce after few times , after uke once told seme himself that "I know you wanted me dead in battlefield i m sorry I come back alive I know luce told me that " seme thought to himself maybe he never knew what type of person luce was he hidden his true self from send misunderstanding of "uke abandoning seme" resolved here seme become softer towards uke and gentles behaviour uke become uncomfortable with that , seme is not affectionate type unless it was luce in uke memories seme always look at uke with anger, disgusted look who knew his feelings and never wanted him near him. Uke never lusted after seme , uke always been hungry for affection whenever seme shows him affection and gentles uke thought " it's bread crumbs seme is throwing at him as throw at dog cuz of his gentle nature he can't possibly treat me badly" , after luce changed lot in 5th timeline seme finally told that he won't be meeting luce anymore, they parted just that and seme always cling to uke like a spouse who shows affection uke become accumsmed his behaviour they even went to beach and seme finally told uke that "I won't be meeting luce anymore he is not same and i never loved him lot has changed in this timeline" uke become terrified and cried in front of seme and said "did I ruin everything again? How could it be did i apart both of you again? I m the reason it happened he is love of your life I think I m mistaken again" before seme process uke thought, uke with his crippled leg goes right to beach to die again thinking he still need to revive to make things right again seme stopped him and told uke that "I don't love luce, i want you Hernan , want us to leave past behind and be happy and start a new" after lots of struggle uke understood till seme didn't stop he cling to uke and confess as they gotten closer become lover uke still believed seme deserve someone better not him , after that time of seme leaving for battlefield reach he and " promised to uke that wait for me 2 years and don't want to divorce uke , I will be back as hero with a title " uke agreed and wait for seme , seme keep sending letters to uke from his battlefield with different flowers he encountered in his journey till they reach uke they withered but uke loved how lovely those letter were from seme after half year passed letters stopped Coming uke thought seme must be busy , till time come of returns and he no longer had memories of only " his spouse, Hernan uke" , by rumours from others they told seme that "he is victim in marriage and uke is bad old crippled perverted man who locked up seme" seme thought of divorcing uke since uke sound like bad call by others , but he was curious to know uke himself, as uke gets to know seme has forgotten only him he was sad devasted didn't resent seme but himself for still hoping for love he can't have , but uke saw this as opportunity and have seme better companion not me but someone in Empire who would be just like seme , after seme reach scala uke mansion and told uke that he don't know him and uke prepared the divorce papers and told seme ti signed them but seme was curious "if he kept me locked up on mansion and wanted me so bad why he is ready to divorce me so soon" also settlement is disadvantage for uke , everything wealth and Penny of his will go to seme after divorce, a crippled man like uke needed assistant how he would survive, seme of without memories fell for uke slowly after he strike deal with uke ti give him time he would make uke fell for him , meanwhile uke always kept thd portrait of seme in his pocket, it as that forest god who removed seme memories since seme got his memories back but uke was happy when seme lost his memories who confessed and said "i love you " ti uke without hesitation after lot happened finally seme got memories and he keep clinging to uke like leech uke doesn't trust seme even till the end he thought it's all dream and this world will scatter anytime, they eventually have consent sex it was good actually uke was Total innocent and seme was eager to have it , tbh uke was scared ri touch seme first himself he thought seme would find him disgusting but iy was opposite seme was sexually attracted to uke and keep getting hard on slightest touch from uke , later on SMS finally made matching rings and proposed to uke , seme again wanted a marriage since uke wouldn't agree to it now he would ask him and seme every day without fail tells uke "I love you" make his worried go away he knows what uke thinks so he always read up uke easily never put him in difficult situation.


My review - it was good and sad read uke struggle and every person who tells him that "he doesn't deserve seme he is broken and all" those all words hurts me a lot , those who said talking about kids there is no mention of that here seme was happy as two only , also seme become cane for uke leg he watches and read uke mind and never push him against his will. Good part about this story has lots of passionate kisss than sex, no Sa just pure angst of emotions. I m excited to see these all emotions in manhwa but i don't think manhwa would be able convey all these emotions...

The “it’s fiction, learn to differentiate reality” argument is so tired. I KNOW it’s fiction. Fiction can still normalize and romanticize harmful behavior. And let’s be honest, the ML being attractive absolutely affects how people excuse what he does. There are literally real-life cases where attractive criminals received massive public sympathy because of their looks.

The issue isn’t rape simply existing in fiction; it’s how it’s repeatedly sexualized, romanticized, and excused when the perpetrator is the attractive ML. Authors rarely show the actual psychological aftermath either: PTSD, fear, withdrawal, difficulty trusting people, and long-term trauma. They skip that reality because actually portraying it would make it obvious how horrific rape is instead of making it look like “dark romance.”

And please don’t hit me with the “people watch murder mysteries and don’t become murderers” argument. Murder and rape aren’t interchangeable, especially when one is being repeatedly romanticized as part of a dark romance. And the normalization literally shows in the comments when people say, “MC deserved it.” Imagine saying that about an actual victim. Then when someone calls it out, you ask, “Why are you taking fiction so seriously?” THAT is exactly the problem. You’ve become so desensitized to it that rape is being treated like a casual plot device.

KinkApex like topic of Love Recycling

im reading novel right now and i genuinely think im going to die from feeling so sorry for mun yeong. please dont get mad at him for not standing up for himself. HE IS BEEN THROUGH SO MUCH. he is never received love from a single person since the day he was born and has been pushed around his entire life. you cant expect someone who is lived like that not to get used to it. he is so used to being treated like absolute shit that he doesnt even get hurt by those words anymore. IM GOING TO DIE FROM FEELING SO BAD FOR HIM. PLEASE BE KIND TO HIM AND LOVE HIM SO MUCH. I WANT TO GIVE HIM MY WHOLE WORLD WRAP HIM UP IN THE BIGGEST HUG AND PROTECT HIM FOREVER also love isnt one sided. haejeong is in love too bur he just doesnt realize it yet. we are going to have to wait a long time before his character development finally kicks in..

KinkApex like topic of Place to Be

Okay, after reading all the spoilers, I'm sorry but the uke deserved so much fucking better than this piece of shit seme. I'm dropping this fucking mess.

My problem isn't that the seme didn't love the uke back at first. Nobody owes anyone romantic feelings. My problem is that this selfish motherfucker knowingly took advantage of the uke's feelings. He knew the uke loved him. He knew the uke was too kind and too timid to ever ask for anything in return. So what does this asshole do? He accepts the love, the emotional support, the favors, the comfort, and even fucks him while fully believing he'll never love him back. Then he has the audacity to think sex will somehow make the uke "give up." What kind of fucked up logic is that? You're literally sleeping with someone who's hopelessly in love with you while planning to reject them forever.

On top of that, this dude is a complete fucking hypocrite. He's out here acting like sex doesn't mean love, sleeping around, and treating physical intimacy so casually when it benefits him. But the second someone else gets close to the uke, the second another guy kisses him or a girl leaves hickeys on him, he loses his absolute fucking mind. Suddenly he's throwing punches, acting possessive, and behaving like the uke belongs to him. So it's perfectly fine when he uses the uke's body for his own comfort, but the moment someone else touches the uke, it's the end of the fucking world? Fuck off with that hypocritical bullshit.

Then this dickhead still wants the uke to stay by his side as a "friend" because he doesn't want to be lonely after losing his own unrequited love. You don't get to reject someone, use them as your emotional crutch, and still expect them to stick around because it makes your life easier.

The most infuriating part is that this dumb fuck knows exactly what unrequited love feels like. He spent years obsessing over another man. He knows how miserable it is. He knows how impossible it is to move on when that person is still in your life. Yet he still expects the uke to stay because he's "strong enough." Strong enough for what? To keep suffering so your pathetic ass has someone to lean on? That's selfish as hell.

Then, after years of taking the uke for granted, this fucking idiot only starts realizing his feelings because someone else might have him. He sees the uke share one simple kiss with another guy and suddenly loses his shit. A girl leaves hickeys on the uke, and he goes absolutely fucking ballistic. He beats up his own friends because they didn't stop it, didn't tell him about the uke's job, and because they were close to the uke. He isn't suddenly some misunderstood romantic. He's panicking because the person he always assumed would wait forever might actually move on.

Then the uke gets sexually assaulted while working as a designated driver. The seme storms into the club, beats the shit out of the owner, punches the guy he used to love because they knew about the job and didn't stop what happened. Sure, anyone would be furious about the assault, but let's not pretend his possessiveness isn't mixed into it. The uke tells him they aren't together and that it's none of his business, and that's when reality finally bitch-slaps him. He realizes he has absolutely no fucking claim over the uke.

After all that bullshit, they have rough sex. The next morning the uke wakes up sick, thinks he's been abandoned, and leaves for his hometown. Later the seme waits anxiously outside the uke's store, they talk things out, and eventually start dating because now he suddenly wants to be considerate. Wow, how fucking convenient.

And where the fuck is this so-called chasing arc everyone keeps hyping up? This isn't a chasing arc. This is a "holy shit, my safety net is leaving" arc. The seme doesn't spend chapters genuinely reflecting on how badly he fucked up or trying to earn the uke's forgiveness. He starts acting differently because he's terrified of losing the one person who always loved him unconditionally.

The uke spent years quietly suffering, watching the man he loved pine after someone else, never expecting anything in return, and still giving everything he had. Meanwhile, the seme benefited from all of it without a second thought. Then the second the uke starts slipping away, it's suddenly, "Oh fuck, I think I'm in love." Nah. Miss me with that bullshit. The uke deserved way better than this selfish, hypocritical, emotionally constipated fuckboy.

That scene in Chapter 15 of the manhwa is a subtle spoiler. The moment when the FL looks at the ML and Kailus goes along with it with an uneasy expression… But since the first half of the novel is told mainly from Richard’s POV, what we’re shown may not be the whole truth. The story looks like a comedy at first, but from around chapter 80 onward, the novel goes completely wild, with twist after twist until the very end. Every character is insane in their own way.

Everyone is unhinged, twisted, and psychologically messed up. The biggest reveal is that the regressors aren’t limited to just one or two characters; there are actually far more of them than you’d ever expect.

I’m afraid that if people wait for the translation to come out chapter by chapter, many of them will probably drop it halfway. But since I read the whole thing in one go, I actually made it all the way to the end. Sometimes I even forgot this was supposed to be a BL. The main genres honestly feel more like fantasy, isekai and psychological

This might be a major spoiler and almost a full reveal, but knowing this may help you decide whether you want to keep reading. Richard truly loves Daphne because his character and his “role” were created that way. The reason the story never truly ends is because Richard himself is the one who refuses to let her go.

All of the main characters have regressed to the point where they’ve broken away from the personalities and roles originally written for them. They chose not to follow the script anymore. But the reason the story keeps repeating and refuses to end is ultimately because Richard can’t stop loving Daphne.

Daphne is the only one who isn’t originally from this world. She is an outsider, a foreign existence that slipped into this world. She is a reader whose soul entered the story and took over the FL’s body. There is no yuri in this story. Daphne is practically another main character who remains important until the very end.

Some readers might feel uncomfortable because the author may not seem to portray the women in the story very favorably. However, when you look at the male characters individually, none of them are truly good either. That’s why, like I said, everyone in this story is crazy and psychologically messed up. The least insane(or not?) person is probably the protagonist’s father, the king.

As I mentioned, this story is truly twists beyond twists, and every character’s love is intense, extreme, and completely unhinged, just like how Richard would do anything for Daphne.

And… Richard only remembers regressing for the 49th time, but the truth is that the story we are reading right now is only one of countless timelines that have occurred. This timeline will collapse as well, and the story will continue through countless other timelines, both past and present. Before Richard became aware of the truth, there had already been thousands, even tens of thousands of regressions carried out by other characters, including Daphne and Kailus.

The reason Richard became aware of the truth was because Daphne was the one who told him that they were living inside a novel. When Richard became aware of the “truth” of this world during his first regression, that was what turned him into a regressor. What I mean is that once any character learns that this world is actually a novel, they are no longer just characters following the script. They become self-aware and realize that they are regressors.

I haven’t talked about Daphne much, but don’t underestimate her. Her role in this story is far more important than it seems. She is one of the most significant characters and… perhaps the most unexpected and unpredictable one.

And my favorite character goes to………… Wilmar! Should I say more about him? He’s definitely not a good person, and he’s just as unhinged as everyone else in this story. But somehow, I still ended up feeling sorry for him. I couldn’t help but root for him and want to see him succeed.

KinkApex like topic of Healer

the lack of empathy for coca in this comment section is so odd... what exactly has he done that was so bad???

If anyone is trying to read this expecting some taboo but wholesome smut. DON'T. it's just rape. And I heard apparently there's a novel and the brothers are actually biological in that one.

KinkApex like question

Looking for manga where either
1. Dark haired seme was r@ped as a child or otherwise
2. Dark haired male character in other genre was r@ped as a child
3. Dark haired seme who was an uke before

Although r@pe is r@pe, I am looking for male on male where DARK haired seme/male character was bottom. and not reverse rape or with female.

I am ONLY looking for manga with above cases pertaining to DARK haired person.

I already have

https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/sakura_gari/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/soine_lovers/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/yondaime_ooyamato_tatsuyuki/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/yuigon/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/puppy_play_with_papa/uu/br_chapter-104972/pg-39/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/shounen_to_kamikakushi/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/kyouai_shinri_paradox/

Others
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/totally_captivated/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/mumyoutou/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/neji_no_kaiten/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/life_ain_t_so_bad/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/skin_asada_nemui/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/my_k_kun/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/the_boss_conditions/

Feeling pretty messed by up right now. Just found that seme from Gift was actually r@ped by his brother and father just because he has light hair and eyes. Adding this to all the other cases where where light haired people were r@ped as children.. What are authors exactly trying to imply. This is just plain Racial Domination and disgusting fetishism.

https://www.mangago.me/home/mangatopic/14315920/
https://www.mangago.me/home/mangatopic/14613432/

KinkApex like topic of Cigarette Ash

Kind of spoiler??










I went ahead and read the novel, well part of it. It’s super cliche with financial disparity between the mc and ml. Mc got wrongly accused and is left with a huge debt and the guy who scammed him got him a job at a club. There he met the ml who asked him whether he was selling his “hole” or not, mc declined and left with a good tip again. On the day he was supposed to make a payment he found out that the club basically takes most of your pay and the workers are basically stuck with no option other than selling themselves to make some sort of money. Mc was given a deadline of 3 days and on the third day, he approached the ml to see if the offer was still valid. Ml took him up on It, and the “consensual” not so Consensual stuff happened with mc backing out in the middle but ml not letting him. Later ml only seeked out mc while humiliating it, using violence ( slapping, hitting) and basically being an asshole in general. Mc did accept all this under the circumstances, since the scammer had started harassing his grandma as well. Ive gotten up to the part where ml finally moves to a hotel room instead of the sofa. We are supposed to think there is a little character development because he held the mc’s cheek AFTER he slapped him for not taking his clothes off fast enough because he was worried it may hurt a bit.

I’ll update once I finish.

KinkApex like topic of Retribution

-
-
-
-
-
-
-

They broke up 3x lol that’s how incompatible and they know it lol they are aware

So we already saw the first one
The second one is the common “I’m engage but I’m hiding it to you”

So for few chapters ML and MC will have a good lovey dovey relationship and ML will slightly improve after MC and ML lay out rules for each other MC including that they won’t do sexual stuff in public like how ML used to ask for MC to do sexual favors if he gets jealous. ML’s rules for MC are like don’t say they will break up and Don’t talk to the TA stuff like that

ML is obsessed and possessive towards MC but improved on holding back, occasionally there are things he would say like “if you ever have sec with another man I’d kill you and him” or “We cannot get separated ever” Eventually ML fantasized that MC and Him will live together and with MC agreed to it quickly and they made an excuse to MC’s parents which MC’s parents agreed. ML even fantasized of marrying MC and when he told MC, MC found it lovely and said He’d love to. All is good

Until…….. ML got called by his parents for a dinner gathering because it’s been a while since they had it. ML goes to the dinner gathering and sees his brother and his aunt, aunt then suggest a girl fitting for ML and he should meet her, she came from a wealthy and powerful family and what’s more she is a only child so marrying her means the parents will surely support the future spouse. ML didn’t like the idea but he has to meet her cause father demanded to. ML then didn’t really thought It’d be a big deal since they are just meeting so he didn’t tell Mc. Then the dinner date with that said girl happened, ML then acts cold and ML even noticed that the girl doesn’t seem to view him in affectionate way so he was sure that it won’t lead to marriage talks, but boy he was wrong, it turns out girlie like him cause he is handsome and agrees to the marriage talks, ML then plays along cause it’s what his father and mother wants, and he needs to do everything they want so he can get inherit the company

ML then begins to go home late due to the frequent dates the rich girl was demanding. ML then overtime gets stressed to make his schedule so he can avoid the MC meeting or knowing the girl, at the same time he saw how unbothered MC is whenever he returns to their house late, MC doesn’t confront him with “why are you late?” “Where have you been?” Or “who were you with” begins to doubt if MC still loves him and that pissed him off think that MC’s feeling might have faded a little after their first break up, he got pissed and annoying thinking about it that he blurted out to MC that someone is getting engaged and MC replied “who? Is it your relative? Your cousin?” And ML told him why would that matter? MC replied that he wanted to congratulate the said relative


This pissed ML off even more cause MC didn’t accuse him or get jealous, so he had rough sex with MC and in the morning he straightforwardly told MC that the person he said that was getting engaged was him, MC thought he was joking ML then realized that MC just trust him way too much
(which is true, MC never bothered to ask him about returning home late cause MC trust him so much since they have been in a good relationship now and ML did tell him about his fantasy of getting married with MC)


So ML thinks it’s better and it was good that MC didn’t asked or dig deeper and thinks it was a joke. So ML didnt clarify and hid it. Soon he asked MC to transfer overseas with him and with few convincing MC agreed, MC’s family also agreed cause MC told them that a scholarship will pay his staying (it’s a excuse, ML will shoulder his expenses)

So MC prepares his documents so he gets busy while ML is busy trying to humor his soon to be fiancé he is cold but girlie won’t budge and still ask for dates. MC then after finishing his documents threw a farewell party with his class and friends

TA was there, then after the party TA told him that ML is getting engaged, at first MC didn’t believe him and laugh it off thinking it’s a joke, but TA hit him with “why do you think he wants to take you to states? he is getting engaged in Hawaii, I know cause the professor is invited and I’m the one who processed his tickets” MC then finally realized TA was not joking. He returns to their house and waited for ML then confronted him, in which ML admits and tells MC that he has to do this because he wants to inherit the company. MC then demands for break up

ML then got pissed saying that MC broke all his rules and grapes MC, he then told MC no one is breaking up and stop saying such words. MC then threatened ML that he would cut his wrist if ML won’t agree. ML eventually agreed causing their 2nd break up. Anyways this time MC is for real wanting break up. ML then ambushes him as he wants MC to talk to him about the break up, MC refused and was adamant about the break up


MC then tells ML he is dating the TA and he even slept with him when they broke up. This enraged ML and plans to hurt TA but MC told him you forgot your rules, don’t hurt the TA! Over time ML’s condition was not doing well, he has trouble sleeping and pills don’t work anymore, he went back to his gangster side job to drain his energy but the gangster boss told him it’d be the last time cause his father knew now and warned the gang. He also got scolded cause he didn’t tell the gangster boss that he came from rich family. With that ML starts to demand to MC to leave TA and go back with him, ambushing him locker and started to follow him at night. Eventually TA got the hint that MC is using him as a excuse that they are dating and plays along with it


ML confronts him about the TA but MC still refused and adamantly said he likes TA and is dating TA. Eventually because of ML’s stalking, he spotted TA and MC near MC’s home for context TA walked MC to his house in which MC agrees TA also said to him that he is willing to wait for MC, anyways TA almost going to kiss MC and MC starting to think to maybeeee move on but they didn’t know ML is stalking MC (well semi stalking since he doesn’t do it often) and saw them ML then Punched TA in the jaw so hard it broke, TA starts to collapse and bleed
MC was concerned for TA so he rushed to TA and ML holding him back saying “what do you love him that much?” In which MC replied something along the lines that it’s obvious since they are dating. ML dragged tried to drag MC but I forgot this part I think he failed


Anyways due to that commotion it lead to a chaos, MC went with ML so he doesn’t hurt TA and ML isn’t exactly sober, MC then looks at ML’s phone and found his fiancé number and called her. MC told fiancé that she should pick up ML cause he is drunk. MC meets up fiancé and gave ML to her, after that incident ML didn’t bother MC again but ML eventually broke down and gave up already, reach the point he didn’t care anymore and was annoyed to see his fiancée’s face cause every time he sees it, it reminds him that fiancé is the one who caused the break up. ML humiliated fiancé by telling her to strip cause he wants to sleep with her only to kick her out. Fiancé then had enough and told her father to break the engagement.


ML’s father of course was furious and ask ML to fix it but ML refused so he got hit by his father multiple time. Due to his injuries he takes off from school, when he came up he has bandages and stuff, TA saw him and TA talked to him about the truth that he is in fact is not dating MC and added that although he loves MC he doesn’t love him as much as ML so he is letting go after getting his jaw dislocated I guess.


ML then begged Mc to talk to him, MC gave in cause he sees ML injured and ML told him he knew about TA and stuff. He also told MC he broke up with his fiancé hence the injuries.


Overtime MC forgave him and starts dating ML again.


So time skip, MC is in his senior year and ML starts working in his father’s company. Initially his father planned to give him a high position after graduation but due to breaking his engagement their stock kind of was affected so he was mad and settled ML as a normal office worker for now. So again both MC and ML became lovey dovey again. But MC this time is a bit distant to ML like he didn’t agree that they go back to their cohabitation status and he doesn’t really step foot in ML’s apartment if they date it’s either outside or meet up in MC’s house. Soon ML saw MC applying to the father’s company and figured out that’s why MC has been busy so he went along with MC’s boundaries


But that didn’t take long lol, ML confronts MC why he doesn’t go in his apartment, turns out MC hates it cause it’s where the fiance had visited ML before and he wants some boundaries so that he doesn’t fall deeper to ML. ML sees this as MC thinking that they will break up again (lol foreshadowing) anyways ML went with what Mc wants in the end and this is whyyyyyyy!!!! They got caught by MC’s sister making out in MC’s room. MC’s sister make it a secret to MC but! Confronts ML


MC’s sister is a reporter so she is good at digging stuff and eventually she found out that ML is from a rich family, was engaged before and is the reason why MC didn’t commit to the overseas studying thing. MC’s sister then tells ML to break off the relationship because she knows with ML’s family they would hurt MC if they knew ML is dating him, ML says no and tells sister that he’d be able to protect MC when he gets the company, MC’s sister then tells him that by what means and gave him reality check that now he is powerless and just a office worker.


Added to that issue. ML’s brother found out about MC too and threatened ML that he’d release all ML and MC’s photos if ML does not step down as successor and sell his stocks, reminded him that for ML his family is nothing and something ML can throw but MC is different, he has bones and flesh that can break and he has family that he loves. ML counter’s brother by threatening him of his child outside of marriage. Turns out his brother has a secret love child with a different girl whom he actually love. ML even invented stories that he slept with the said woman (he didn’t)


Eventually with sister’s reality check and brother’s threat ML breaks it off with MC which results their 3rd break up (haaaaizzzz) MC was hurt by this cause he loves ML but after few days ML didn’t last without MC. He dragged MC to a empty equipment storage room and makes out with MC and folded told him the break up is for MC’s protection but he can’t last nor live without MC so he takes it back


ML then went to his father and straight up told him he is dating a man. Father went violent to him and hit him multiple times he had to be rushed to hospital. Which his mother begs the father. Father then didn’t wanna lost his child and eventually accepted to ML dating a man.


After walking up and surviving his near death lol (when he collapse he thought he was gonna die and even told them that he will give MC his shares and if he dies he want MC to believe a fake story of him leaving him and married someone else overseas so MC won’t be depressed and move on)
Anyways he survived so he went to MC’s house and MC’s sister said like wait you broke up with him you can’t see him, but ML was like It’s fine now cause he fixed the issue already and rushed to MC’s room.


MC and ML makes up and ML took him to his apartment and they had sex there. This time fr they won’t break up as they promised


The enddddddd!
Title should be the break up series

KinkApex like topic of Cementation

Another twink/child looking uke
SMDH

Is this the main story and Choice of choices Ji-in's spin off or the other way around? Like this is the spin off of the second lead who wasnt chosen (this story's seme)? Asking because the other webtoon is older so im guessing that is the main story which unfortunately no translation team official or not has picked it up, i remember it was quite interesting

ZIG’s ABO Universe Explanation

The ZIG ABO universe is divided mainly into two interconnected lines:

- the “If You Can” series

- and the “Kiss Me” series.

The “If You Can” series currently has 6 novels, while the “Kiss Me” side also has multiple connected stories and future planned novels. In total, the universe revolves around several powerful dominant alpha families, including:

- the Millers,

- the Pittmans,

- and other elite alpha bloodlines, including a Middle Eastern royal family.

The basic concept of this universe is the idea of “damaged dominant alphas.”

In ZIG’s universe, dominant alpha pheromones can affect brain development and emotional functioning. The earlier a dominant alpha manifests, the more severe the psychological and emotional damage becomes. This is why many dominant alphas in the universe are emotionally unstable, obsessive, detached, or psychologically abnormal. That's the reason they are all called "psychos".

The timing of manifestation is extremely important.

- Keith Pittman, Ashley Miller, and Chase Miller manifested relatively late (around or after puberty), so they retained comparatively normal emotional functioning.

- Ashley later melted his brain due to long-term pheromone extraction through injection treatments(the method that Chase uses).

- Nathaniel manifested around the age of 10, which caused partial damage. He struggled emotionally and appeared detached, but he could still understand and process emotions relatively well.

- Grayson and his twin sister Stacy were BORN DOMINANT alphas, making them among the most severely damaged cases in the universe. Grayson especially developed abnormally because his emotional and social development was affected from birth itself.

- Bliss manifested at the age of 7

“Kiss Me If You Can” mainly acts as the gateway into the “If You Can” universe. It introduces the Miller family conflict and the dangerous side of damaged alphas, but the later novels expand the lore much more deeply.

“Desire Me If You Can” is probably the clearest representation of ZIG’s damaged-alpha concept because Grayson’s character embodies the psychological consequences of the entire system and is the main story of the universe. His story recontextualizes:

- the Miller family,

- pheromone damage,

- the parenting dynamics,

- and many events from KMIYC.

Meanwhile, “Kiss Me, Liar” functions more as the central story of the “Kiss Me” side of the universe. Many connected stories from that side still do not have full novels yet, although Keith’s parents’ generation (“Kiss Me Villains”) is expected to receive a novel first.

One important thing about ZIG’s writing is that most characters are not meant to be viewed as simply “good” or “evil.” The universe is built around how pheromones, trauma, upbringing, and psychological damage distort emotional development and relationships.

KinkApex like topic of Camellia

haha hyou don’t kill yourself you need to be alive to rape your little brother. Haha don’t kys man